Howdy chadsawyeragencycom,
That’s no good. After taking a look at your site I am seeing some Javascript errors in the console. Those could very well be the cause of the problem. Unfortunately they might require a programmer to help you diagnose. Did one help you build or customize this site perchance?
One thing you can do without a programmer is conflict testing. Sometimes the latest versions of two plugins, or even your theme and a plugin, no longer play well together. And now that WordPress can autoupdate some stuff it could even be that it broke automatically, without you doing a thing! This guide will help you test if something is conflicting. If something is, it then walks you through identifying what is conflicting. Once we know that there might be an easy fix!
Please let me know if you have questions. I am happy to help. Cheers!
– Brook